clock menu more-arrow no yes
A pumpkin pie with whipped cream dollops and pecans from A La Mode
Pumpkin pie from A La Mode
A La Mode/Instagram

Where to Order Delectable Pies in Seattle This Fall

Pumpkin, pecan, sweet potato, buko, and beyond

View as Map
Pumpkin pie from A La Mode
| A La Mode/Instagram

The holidays must necessarily look much different this year. As Gov. Jay Inslee stated, large family gatherings are simply not a safe option with COVID cases spiking to alarming levels across the state. Still, many can celebrate Thanksgiving with members of their own household or solo, and a great pie is a must at any dinner table, even for more Zoom-oriented conversations. Here are just a few of the best local options for takeout.

Read More
Note: Restaurants on this map are listed geographically.

1. A La Mode Pies

Copy Link
5821 Phinney Ave N
Seattle, WA 98103
(206) 383-3796
Visit Website

Phinney Ridge's pie haven, which expanded to West Seattle, has some wonderful rotating seasonal concoctions, including a brûléed pumpkin for the holidays, the Blue Hawaiian (blueberries, crushed pineapple, and toasted coconut), and Mexican chocolate mousse. Both locations are open for online orders.

2. Pie Bar Ballard

Copy Link
2218 NW Market St
Seattle, WA 98107
(206) 535-8489
Visit Website

Specializing in both savory and sweet options, this longtime favorite should have something for everyone, whether it’s the vegan crimini mushroom pot pie or the Bumble Berry Crumble (with Granny Smith apples, strawberries, blackberries, and raspberries). There are even some cocktails available to go for those who want to booze it up with dessert. Takeout only

3. Simply Soulful

Copy Link
2909B E Madison St
Seattle, WA 98112
(206) 474-9841
Visit Website

Madison Valley’s mother-daughter pie shop specializes in sweet potato pies (and tarts), which are available all year ‘round, but are especially great around the holidays. They come in 9-inch and 5-inch tins, and are available for preordering via phone.

A view of sweet potato pies at Simply Soulful in small tins
Sweet potato pies at Simply Soulful
Simply Soulful [Official Photo]

4. Macrina Bakery

Copy Link
2408 1st Ave
Seattle, WA 98121
(206) 448-4032
Visit Website

Known city-wide for some of the best bread around, the biggest fall craving the company bakes up is for its mini maple apple pie, topped with maple sugar. Other seasonal offerings include a brandied orange pecan pie and a streusel pumpkin. They’re available for delivery through DoorDash.

5. Hood Famous Cafe and Bar

Copy Link
504 5th Ave S #107a
Seattle, WA 98104
(206) 485-7049
Visit Website

International District’s popular Filipino cafe may have developed a following for its famed ube cheesecake, but diners shouldn’t sleep on some of the other items from James Beard Award-nominated chef Chera Amlag. There’s a creamy buko pie and a haupia pie bar sprinkled with candied pumpkin seeds that must not be missed. Available for online preorders.

6. Baked from the Hart

Copy Link
2801 S Hanford St
Seattle, WA 98144
(206) 650-9191
Visit Website

This Mount Baker shop has been operating since 2016, but owner Bill Hart’s baking experience goes back decades, and that dedication shows in his delightful Southern-influenced creations. His chess pies (in flavors such as key lime, coconut, and lemon) are critically acclaimed, and everything is available for online orders.

A closeup of a key lime chess pie from Baked from the Hart
Key lime chess pie
Baked from the Hart [Official Photo]

7. Bakery Nouveau

Copy Link
4737 California Ave SW
Seattle, WA 98116
(206) 923-0534
Visit Website

Though many fans come to this West Seattle bakery (with locations in Burien and on Capitol Hill) for the twice-baked croissants, the multitalented shop also produces an impressive selection of rotating and seasonal pies and tarts. Dutch apple, coconut creme, and chocolate pecan are just a few favorites. Available for online preorders.

8. Cakes of Paradise

Copy Link
6322 6th Ave S
Seattle, WA 98108
(206) 763-1151
Visit Website

The name may say “cakes” but the menu screams “pie,” with bright, Hawaiian-influenced options like mango cream cheese and macadamia nut cream pie. It’s a bit of a welcome departure for a city filled with more flaky-crust varieties and local fruit. Available for online orders, but some of the bakery’s treats can also be found for retail at Uwajimaya.

9. High 5 Pie

Copy Link
11620 Ambaum Blvd SW
Burien, WA 98146
(206) 244-4303
Visit Website

This former Capitol Hill pie shop is now housed at Burien’s Salmon Creek Cafe, but it’s still serving up a selection of classics, from banana cream to cherry to key lime. And the marionberry crumb is always on point. All are available for online preorders.

1. A La Mode Pies

5821 Phinney Ave N, Seattle, WA 98103

Phinney Ridge's pie haven, which expanded to West Seattle, has some wonderful rotating seasonal concoctions, including a brûléed pumpkin for the holidays, the Blue Hawaiian (blueberries, crushed pineapple, and toasted coconut), and Mexican chocolate mousse. Both locations are open for online orders.

5821 Phinney Ave N
Seattle, WA 98103

2. Pie Bar Ballard

2218 NW Market St, Seattle, WA 98107

Specializing in both savory and sweet options, this longtime favorite should have something for everyone, whether it’s the vegan crimini mushroom pot pie or the Bumble Berry Crumble (with Granny Smith apples, strawberries, blackberries, and raspberries). There are even some cocktails available to go for those who want to booze it up with dessert. Takeout only

2218 NW Market St
Seattle, WA 98107

3. Simply Soulful

2909B E Madison St, Seattle, WA 98112
A view of sweet potato pies at Simply Soulful in small tins
Sweet potato pies at Simply Soulful
Simply Soulful [Official Photo]

Madison Valley’s mother-daughter pie shop specializes in sweet potato pies (and tarts), which are available all year ‘round, but are especially great around the holidays. They come in 9-inch and 5-inch tins, and are available for preordering via phone.

2909B E Madison St
Seattle, WA 98112

4. Macrina Bakery

2408 1st Ave, Seattle, WA 98121

Known city-wide for some of the best bread around, the biggest fall craving the company bakes up is for its mini maple apple pie, topped with maple sugar. Other seasonal offerings include a brandied orange pecan pie and a streusel pumpkin. They’re available for delivery through DoorDash.

2408 1st Ave
Seattle, WA 98121

5. Hood Famous Cafe and Bar

504 5th Ave S #107a, Seattle, WA 98104

International District’s popular Filipino cafe may have developed a following for its famed ube cheesecake, but diners shouldn’t sleep on some of the other items from James Beard Award-nominated chef Chera Amlag. There’s a creamy buko pie and a haupia pie bar sprinkled with candied pumpkin seeds that must not be missed. Available for online preorders.

504 5th Ave S #107a
Seattle, WA 98104

6. Baked from the Hart

2801 S Hanford St, Seattle, WA 98144
A closeup of a key lime chess pie from Baked from the Hart
Key lime chess pie
Baked from the Hart [Official Photo]

This Mount Baker shop has been operating since 2016, but owner Bill Hart’s baking experience goes back decades, and that dedication shows in his delightful Southern-influenced creations. His chess pies (in flavors such as key lime, coconut, and lemon) are critically acclaimed, and everything is available for online orders.

2801 S Hanford St
Seattle, WA 98144

7. Bakery Nouveau

4737 California Ave SW, Seattle, WA 98116

Though many fans come to this West Seattle bakery (with locations in Burien and on Capitol Hill) for the twice-baked croissants, the multitalented shop also produces an impressive selection of rotating and seasonal pies and tarts. Dutch apple, coconut creme, and chocolate pecan are just a few favorites. Available for online preorders.

4737 California Ave SW
Seattle, WA 98116

8. Cakes of Paradise

6322 6th Ave S, Seattle, WA 98108

The name may say “cakes” but the menu screams “pie,” with bright, Hawaiian-influenced options like mango cream cheese and macadamia nut cream pie. It’s a bit of a welcome departure for a city filled with more flaky-crust varieties and local fruit. Available for online orders, but some of the bakery’s treats can also be found for retail at Uwajimaya.

6322 6th Ave S
Seattle, WA 98108

9. High 5 Pie

11620 Ambaum Blvd SW, Burien, WA 98146

This former Capitol Hill pie shop is now housed at Burien’s Salmon Creek Cafe, but it’s still serving up a selection of classics, from banana cream to cherry to key lime. And the marionberry crumb is always on point. All are available for online preorders.

11620 Ambaum Blvd SW
Burien, WA 98146

Related Maps